How Judging and Prospecting Personalities Can Lead Better in Uncertain Times
Are you managing the problem or just managing how uncomfortable you feel?
What’s Coming Up
Why Judging leaders’ need for a plan sometimes makes the situation worse, not better
What happens when you mistake having a decision for having the right decision
How Prospecting leaders’ flexibility can accidentally leave their teams directionless
The uncomfortable truth about when keeping options open becomes refusing to lead
How to recognize your patterns and notice whether you’re managing the problem or just managing how uncomfortable you feel
Have a topic idea you’d like to see us cover? Join the Leadership Council and let us know!
When uncertainty hits, Judging leaders want to close it down by making a plan and deciding on a direction. Prospecting leaders want to keep it open by staying flexible and seeing what develops.
Both believe their approach helps their team navigate the unknown.
But sometimes when you’re handling ambiguity, you can unconsciously act in a way that makes you feel less helpless – not in a way that responds to what the situation needs.
Let’s dig into that together today and look at how Judging and Prospecting types experience the weight of uncertainty.
P.S. For more information on how to lead your team (rather than yourself) through stress and uncertainty based on their personality traits, check out our past Managing Stress series.
How Judging Leaders React When Uncertainty Hits
If you’re a Judging leader, uncertainty probably makes you want to decide something (anything!) to replace the ambiguity with structure.
But sometimes that sense of urgency is about feeling relief rather than finding clarity. Deciding something, even if it’s not quite right, feels better than sitting in the not-knowing.
You might notice yourself getting frustrated when new information emerges that doesn’t fit your plan. Instead of reconsidering, you dismiss it or try to force it into your existing framework.
In this moment, the plan itself becomes more important than adapting to what’s actually happening. You’re treating “having a direction” as the same as “having control.” But uncertainty doesn’t care about your plan. The structure you create might comfort you while giving your team false confidence that you’ve figured something out that you actually haven’t.
In uncertain times, rigid plans can create the illusion of stability rather than stability itself.
How to Stretch
Keep reading with a 7-day free trial
Subscribe to Leadership by 16Personalities to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.